Exterior Help Needed

We're trying to figure out what to do with the outside of our house. The two colours that we have narrowed it down to are kind of a butter cream colour, and then a red rock colour. Here are the samples we've created.

Here's the red rock colour with the twighlight grey shingles:

Here's the buttercream colour with the twighlight grey shingles:

I really REALLY love the red one. I think Ryan's leaning that way too, but I'm not sure. It's going to be a stucco outside, but we're meeting with Lyle tonight to see if he has any ideas for us. We'll see what happens!